So we are at Planned Parenthood. Maybe.
John Boehner and Harry Reid are disagreeing about where their difference are at the moment. According to the Speaker, the issue of the riders attached to H.R. 1 have been agreed upon and all that is left is a final total of cuts. Mr. Reid is insisting an alternate version of finalized budget numbers and disagreements on the policy riders of H.R. 1.
Who is telling the truth? It doesn’t matter. All that matter is who is controlling the debate and today that is obviously the Congressional Democrats.
Both Reid and Boehner are probably stretching the truth a bit. They’ve probably not agreed on anything, but, as I said, the truth doesn’t matter politically. It matters who is controlling the debate and the Democrats are quickly making this budget fight a referendum on Planned Parenthood and the Republican House Leadership are being set up for a losing battle.
According to a Quinnipiac poll from just one month ago, the American public opposes defunding Planned Parenthood by a 53%-43% margin. The numbers are even grimmer when you look at moderates who oppose defunding Planned Parenthood by a margin of 23%.
There is still hope for Republicans, but they quickly need to realize that today is only the first battle in a larger war consisting of 3 increasingly important battles: the FY2011 Budget, Increase of the Debt Limit, and the FY2012 Budget.
Senator Pat Toomey(R-PA) has been “the smartest man in the room” for the Republicans. He was honest with his constituency. For Toomey, this fight is peanuts and the Republicans should be focusing the debate on the debt limit and the FY2012 budget. Battles that they can win without the Pyhrric victory that is even seeming more unlikely with each passing news cycle.
If the Democrats complete their flanking motion on defunding of Planned Parenthood, not only will they probably win this small potatoes budget fight, they will have the upper hand on the much more important fights on the debt limit and FY2012 budget.